Should I take money from my IRA or my brokerage account first?
August 18, 2025
By
Category: Investment Management
When it comes to retirement withdrawals, one of the biggest decisions is figuring out whether to take money from your IRA or your brokerage account first. This decision can impact your taxes, Social Security benefits, healthcare costs, and even your lifestyle. Choosing the right strategy helps ensure your money lasts as long as you do and that you minimize unnecessary taxes.
Understanding the Difference Between IRAs and Brokerage Accounts
Before making withdrawal decisions, it helps to understand the difference between the two types of accounts:
IRA (Individual Retirement Account)
- Contributions may be tax-deductible depending on your plan.
- Earnings grow tax-deferred.
- Withdrawals in retirement are taxed as ordinary income.
- Early withdrawals before age 59½ may face penalties unless certain conditions are met.
Brokerage Account
- Contributions are made with after-tax money.
- Earnings may be taxed as capital gains.
- You can access funds anytime without penalties, although taxes on gains apply.
- Offers flexibility since there are no required minimum distributions (RMDs) before age 73.
Understanding these differences is the first step in deciding which account to tap first.
Tax Implications of Your Withdrawal Strategy
Taxes are often the largest factor in retirement planning decisions. Here’s how they differ between accounts:
- IRA Withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income. This could push you into a higher tax bracket if you withdraw too much in one year.
- Brokerage Account Withdrawals may be taxed at lower long-term capital gains rates if you held investments for over a year.
- Taking money from a brokerage account first can sometimes reduce the amount of IRA income you need, helping you stay in a lower tax bracket.
A tax-efficient strategy often balances withdrawals between accounts to minimize the overall tax hit each year. Working with a financial advisor can help you model different scenarios.
Social Security Considerations
The timing of withdrawals can also affect your Social Security benefits.
- Large IRA withdrawals can increase your taxable income, which could lead to more of your Social Security benefits being taxed.
- Delaying IRA withdrawals while using brokerage funds first may help reduce taxes on Social Security income.
- Strategic withdrawals can make it possible to delay claiming Social Security, which increases the monthly benefit you receive for life.
Planning your withdrawals with Social Security in mind can help maximize your retirement income over the long term.
Health Insurance and Medicare Impact
If you retire before age 65, health insurance costs become a critical factor. How you withdraw funds can affect these costs:
- High IRA withdrawals can increase your Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI), potentially raising your premiums for health insurance under the Affordable Care Act.
- Using brokerage funds first may keep your MAGI lower, keeping premiums more affordable.
- Once on Medicare, the withdrawal strategy still matters for supplemental insurance and Part B or Part D premiums, which are based on income.
By considering healthcare costs, you can avoid surprises and maintain your lifestyle without overpaying for insurance.
Lifestyle Benefits of Different Withdrawal Strategies
Retirement is not just about money. It’s about how you live.
- Using brokerage funds first can provide flexibility since you are not locked into IRA rules or RMDs.
- If you want to spend on travel, hobbies, or other big-ticket items early in retirement, tapping your brokerage account may give you the most freedom.
- IRA withdrawals later in retirement can then cover required minimum distributions while minimizing taxes and preserving more of your estate.
Lifestyle planning goes hand-in-hand with taxes and healthcare to create a retirement that is financially secure and personally fulfilling.
Strategies to Consider
Here are a few strategies commonly used by retirees:
Brokerage First, IRA Later
- Use brokerage funds to cover expenses early in retirement.
- Delay IRA withdrawals to reduce taxes and Social Security taxation.
- Beneficial if you plan to delay Social Security or need to manage healthcare premiums.
Balanced Approach
- Take smaller amounts from both accounts each year.
- Helps control taxable income and can keep you in a lower tax bracket.
- Offers flexibility to cover expenses while optimizing Social Security benefits.
IRA First Strategy
- In some cases, early IRA withdrawals can make sense, especially if capital gains taxes on your brokerage account would be high.
- May be useful if you need income for healthcare premiums or to meet early retirement goals.
Every retirement situation is different. A financial advisor can help you analyze your accounts, taxes, Social Security, and lifestyle goals to craft a personalized withdrawal plan.
Planning Ahead is Key
The decision of whether to take money from your IRA or your brokerage account first is rarely simple. It depends on taxes, Social Security implications, healthcare costs, and lifestyle goals.
Taking time to plan withdrawals strategically can:
- Minimize taxes over the course of your retirement
- Maximize Social Security benefits
- Reduce healthcare costs and premium surprises
- Provide financial freedom for lifestyle choices
Working with a professional ensures you make decisions that align with your long-term goals and that you do not unintentionally trigger higher taxes or penalties.
Next Steps
If you are unsure which account to tap first, start by reviewing your current balances, expected expenses, and tax situation. Then:
- Model different withdrawal strategies to see how they impact taxes, Social Security, and health insurance
- Revisit your strategy each year as income needs, tax laws, and healthcare costs change
- Work with a trusted financial advisor to craft a tax-efficient, lifestyle-focused plan
At Guerra Wealth Advisors, we help retirees navigate these choices with confidence. Contact us to create a withdrawal plan tailored to your retirement goals.
More Timely Financial Wisdom
At What Net Worth Should I Get a Financial Advisor?
Many people assume you need to have a certain amount of money saved before working with a financial advisor. Maybe…
What Does a Retirement Income Plan Include?
Retirement planning is about more than simply saving enough money to leave your job. Once you retire, you need a…
What Questions Should I Ask a Financial Advisor Before Hiring One?
Choosing a financial advisor is an important decision. After all, you’re trusting someone to help guide your financial future, manage…
